NUTRITION — target, delivery, and cumulative deficit ============================================================================ Idea 44. Prescribed versus actually delivered. A persistent and quietly consequential gap.
WHY THE GAP PERSISTS -------------------- Feeding is interrupted constantly — for procedures, extubation, imaging, high gastric residuals, position changes. Each interruption is individually reasonable and individually small. Nobody tracks the cumulative total, so a patient can receive half their prescribed calories for a week while every decision along the way was correct.
That is a hold-without-decay problem, not a judgement problem.
PROTEIN IS THE WORSE FAILURE ---------------------------- Measured delivery: 83% of calorie targets, 65% of protein targets. Protein is under-delivered further and noticed less, because the volume looks adequate — a standard feed run at rate reaches calorie targets long before it reaches protein ones.
OVER-FEEDING EARLY IS ALSO HARM ------------------------------- ESPEN specifies a progressive ramp, not a target from day one. Full feeding in the first 48-72 hours causes harm, so the engine must flag over-delivery early as well as under-delivery later. A tool that only ever says "feed more" would be wrong for the first three days.
Sources: ESPEN guideline on clinical nutrition in the ICU (2019, revised 2023). ASPEN/SCCM guidelines. EuroPN observational cohort.
meta
version0.1.0
ownerUNASSIGNED — set to the responsible clinician or dietitian
verified bynot set
energy
unitkcal/kg/day
ramp
- {day from1, day_to: 1, kcal_per_kg: 10}
- {day from2, day_to: 3, kcal_per_kg: 15}
- {day from4, day_to: 6, kcal_per_kg: 20}
- {day from7, day_to: null, kcal_per_kg: 25}
why
ESPENprogressive increase to 25 kcal/kg. The target on day 1 is 10, not
25 — reaching full feeding early causes harm.
protein
unitg/kg/day
ramp
- {day from1, day_to: 1, g_per_kg: 0.6}
- {day from2, day_to: 3, g_per_kg: 0.9}
- {day from4, day_to: null, g_per_kg: 1.3}
full target range[1.2, 2.0]
why
The measured gap is worse for protein than calories — 65% against 83%.
A standard feed run at rate reaches calorie targets long before protein
ones, so the volume looks adequate while the protein is not.
weight
basisactual
use adjusted above bmi30
adjusted formulaideal + 0.25 x (actual - ideal)
note
Actual body weight for most patients. Above BMI 30, adjusted body weight
avoids over-feeding — fat mass is not metabolically active in the way the
calculation assumes.
delivery
adequate fraction0.80
poor fraction0.60
overfeeding fraction1.10
deficit window days3
cumulative deficit kcal flag6000
why cumulative
A single day at 70% is unremarkable. Five consecutive days at 70% is a
deficit of several thousand calories that nobody added up.
interruptions
avoidable
"Fasting for a procedure that was postponed"
"Fasting beyond the required window"
"Feed stopped for a position change and not restarted"
"Waiting for a post-pyloric tube that was never placed"
unavoidable
"Active resuscitation"
"Bowel obstruction or ischaemia"
"Uncontrolled shock"
flag hours per day6
note
Six hours of interruption in a day is a quarter of the target lost.
Recording the reason distinguishes an avoidable pause from a necessary one.
refeeding
risk factors
"Little or no intake for more than 5 days"
"BMI under 16"
"Unintentional weight loss over 15% in 3-6 months"
"Low potassium, phosphate or magnesium before feeding"
"History of alcohol misuse"
action
Start at 25% of target, advance over 3-5 days, and monitor phosphate,
potassium and magnesium daily. Refeeding syndrome is the one situation
where slow delivery is correct and the engine must not push for more.
checks
- idno_nutrition_started
severitywarn
textNo nutrition started
whyEnteral feeding should begin within 48 hours unless contraindicated.
- idunder_delivered
severitywarn
textDelivered below target
whyThe commonest gap, and rarely visible on any single day.
- idprotein_under_delivered
severitywarn
textProtein below target
why
Under-delivered further than calories and noticed less. The volume looks
adequate because calorie targets are reached first.
- idcumulative_deficit
severitywarn
textCumulative deficit building
why
Individually reasonable interruptions summing to a deficit nobody added
up. This is the finding the engine exists for.
- idover_fed_early
severitywarn
textDelivered above the ramp for this day
why
Full feeding in the first 48-72 hours causes harm. The target on day 1
is 10 kcal/kg, not 25.
- idprolonged_interruption
severitywarn
textFeeding interrupted for a prolonged period
whySix hours is a quarter of the daily target.
- idrefeeding_risk
severitycritical
textRefeeding risk — advance slowly
why
The one situation where slow delivery is correct. The engine must not
push for more.
- idno_target_set
severitywarn
textNo nutrition target recorded
whyDelivery cannot be measured against a target that does not exist.