TRANSFUSION THRESHOLDS ============================================================================ Idea 40. Restrictive transfusion is among the best-evidenced positions in critical care and among the least consistently followed. The gap is adherence, not knowledge.
WHY IT IS NOT FOLLOWED ---------------------- The threshold is not one number. It shifts with cardiac disease, active bleeding, and the clinical question being asked. At 3 AM a haemoglobin of 7.4 in a patient with ischaemic heart disease and a haemoglobin of 7.4 in a stable septic patient look identical on a screen, and only one of them is below its threshold.
THE OTHER HALF: SINGLE UNIT --------------------------- Where transfusion is indicated, one unit then reassess. Two-unit orders are habit rather than evidence, and half of the second units are unnecessary. This is the part of restrictive practice most often skipped even by units that hold the threshold.
Sources: TRICC (NEJM 1999), TRISS (NEJM 2014), TRICS-III (NEJM 2017). AABB International Guidelines 2023. CHEST 2025. ISBT patient blood management: single-unit transfusion.
meta
version0.1.0
ownerUNASSIGNED — set to the responsible clinician
verified bynot set
thresholds
- idactive_bleeding
nameActive major bleeding
conditionactive_bleeding
threshold g dlnot set
why
A haemoglobin measured during active bleeding describes the past. Do not
wait for a number — transfuse to the clinical picture and control the
source.
actionTransfuse to clinical need. The threshold does not apply.
priority0
- idacute_coronary
nameAcute coronary syndrome
conditionacute_coronary_syndrome
threshold g dl8.0
why
The one population where a higher threshold has support. The evidence
remains contested; 8 is the common compromise.
actionConsider transfusion below 8 g/dL.
priority1
contestedtrue
- idcardiac_surgery
namePost cardiac surgery
conditionpost_cardiac_surgery
threshold g dl7.5
why
TRICS-IIIpost-cardiac-surgery patients are safely managed at 7.5 g/dL.
actionTransfuse below 7.5 g/dL.
priority2
- idgeneral
nameGeneral critical care
conditionnot set
threshold g dl7.0
why
TRICC established 7 g/dL for haemodynamically stable ICU patients.
TRISS extended it to septic shock — same mortality, 50% fewer units.
AABB 2023 and CHEST 2025 both recommend it.
actionTransfuse below 7 g/dL.
priority9
single unit
enforcetrue
why
One unit, then reassess. Two-unit orders are habit rather than evidence,
and this is the part of restrictive practice most often skipped even by
units that hold the threshold.
expected rise g dl1.0
recheck after units1
note
One unit raises haemoglobin by roughly 1 g/dL in an adult who is not
bleeding. If it did not, ask why before giving another.
checks
- idtransfused_above_threshold
severitywarn
textTransfused above the threshold
why
The commonest deviation, and the one restrictive practice exists to
prevent. No mortality benefit, and every unit carries risk.
- idbelow_threshold_not_transfused
severitywarn
textBelow threshold and not transfused
why
Restrictive is not the same as withholding. Below the threshold,
transfusion is indicated unless there is a stated reason.
- idmulti_unit_order
severitywarn
textMore than one unit ordered without reassessment
why
Single-unit practicetransfuse one, recheck, decide again. Half of
second units are unnecessary.
- idno_recent_haemoglobin
severitywarn
textNo recent haemoglobin
whyA transfusion decision without a current value is not a decision.
- idcontested_threshold
severityinfo
textThreshold is contested in this population
why
Acute coronary syndrome is the one context where the higher threshold
has support, and the evidence is not settled. Stated rather than hidden.
- idexpected_rise_not_seen
severitywarn
textHaemoglobin did not rise as expected after transfusion
why
One unit should raise haemoglobin by about 1 g/dL. If it did not, the
patient is probably still bleeding — ask why before giving another.
cadence
haemoglobin stale after hours24
note
In a stable patient a daily haemoglobin is sufficient. Anaemia caused by
phlebotomy is real, and a value checked six-hourly on a stable patient is
itself a cause of transfusion.